By Lara Yehia · Last reviewed November 2026
For everyday storage, yes, as long as each lid does the job its maker lists. Ball says its metal lids and its plastic storage lids are BPA-free. The flat metal lid is single-use for canning, and Ball's plastic storage lids aren't made for canning or the microwave.
- The band never touches the food. On a two-piece lid, the food side is the underside of the flat lid and its ring of sealing compound.
- Plastic caps put plastic against the food, sometimes with a silicone ring. Stainless caps put steel and silicone there.
- “BPA-free” tells you one chemical wasn't used. It doesn't tell you the plastic, the heat limit or what the lid is made for.
- A used flat lid can still close a jar of dry goods if it isn't bent or rusty. It shouldn't go back in a canner.
- Salt, acid and damp are hard on metal lids. Plastic doesn't rust, and stainless resists it.
We picked the lids below from what each maker publishes about materials, care and uses. We didn't test them, and this page is about storing food, not canning.
Choosing the containers too? Our non-toxic food storage containers guide checks storage sets part by part.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
The lid we'd start with
For fridge, freezer and pantry jars, Ball's own plastic storage lids keep it simple. They're one piece, so there's no flat lid and band to line up. Ball lists them as BPA-free, dishwasher safe and freezer safe, and its customer team says they're polypropylene (#5). Good to know: Ball lists them as non-canning lids, and its retail listings say they aren't for the microwave.
See Ball wide mouth storage lids on AmazonWhat actually touches your food, lid by lid
A mason jar lid is two or three materials put together, and only some of them face the food. Condensation and splashes reach the whole underside of a closed lid, so we count everything on that side. Here is what sits there on each common type, going by what the makers publish. Where a maker doesn't say, we say so.
| Lid type | What touches the food | What the maker states | Not stated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two-piece metal (flat lid + band) | Underside of the flat lid and its ring of sealing compound. The band screws on over the top and doesn't reach the food. | Ball: BPA-free, and the lid is for one-time use when canning. Ball's FAQ refers to a coating on the lid. | What the coating and the sealing compound are made of |
| One-piece plastic cap (Ball storage lid) | Inside of the plastic cap. | Ball: plastic, BPA-free, non-canning, dishwasher and freezer safe. Ball's team: polypropylene #5. | Whether there's a separate gasket |
| Plastic cap with silicone gasket (Masontops) | Inside of the cap and the silicone gasket. | Masontops: BPA-free and phthalate-free plastic and silicone, dishwasher and freezer safe. | Microwave use |
| Stainless cap with silicone gasket (Ball stainless) | Steel underside and the silicone gasket. | Ball: stainless steel, BPA-free, hand-wash only, not dishwasher or freezer safe, not for preserving. | Steel grade |
| Stainless cap with full silicone liner | Mostly silicone. The liner covers the inside of the lid. | One seller of this style says its liners cover the entire inner surface and lists 18/8 (304) stainless steel. | – |
| Band on its own | Nothing, as long as a flat lid or an insert sits under it. | – | – |
Sources: Ball product pages, Ball FAQ and Ball's retail listings, the Masontops product page and a liner seller's page. Checked 17 November 2026. We did not test any lid.
The sealing compound and the coating
On a flat metal lid, the colored ring near the edge is the sealing compound. It's built to seal once in a canner, which is why Ball says its lids are for one-time use when canning. Ball doesn't publish what the compound or the lid coating is made of. Its canning FAQ does list a scratched coating, and strong salt or acid, among the causes of rust on lids. Replace a lid that is bent, or has rust or scratches on the food side, even for storage.
Illustration: turn a lid over and you see what your food sees: sealing compound, plastic, or steel with a silicone ring.
Does BPA-free mean plastic-free?
No. Ball labels both its two-piece lids and its plastic storage lids BPA-free. That is the maker telling you bisphenol A wasn't used. It isn't the same as plastic-free: the storage lid is still plastic, and the flat metal lid still has a sealing material on its underside. The label also leaves out which plastic it is, what else is in it and how much heat it takes. Our guide to plastic grades for food storage explains how to read those codes.
What a lid suits depends on the job. The US rule for food-container closures with sealing gaskets, 21 CFR 177.1210, sets which materials gaskets can use and how they are tested, matched to the food type and use, such as refrigerated, frozen or hot-filled storage. So the maker's use list tells you more than one label does.
Which lid for which job
Match the lid to what you're storing. The jar matters too: Ball's FAQ lists its jars for canning, cold or room-temperature food storage and cold drinks.
| Job | Lid that fits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Fridge and leftovers | One-piece plastic or stainless storage lid. A two-piece lid works too. | Acidic or salty food sitting against a metal underside. |
| Freezer | A lid its maker lists as freezer safe. Ball plastic, Masontops, AOZITA and EcoPeaceful do. | Ball lists its stainless lids as not freezer safe. The jar has to be freezer safe too, and headspace matters: see how to freeze food in mason jars. |
| Dry pantry | Any clean lid. A used flat lid works if it isn't bent or rusty. | Rust on metal lids. Pick a dry shelf. To pull the air out, see which lids work with a mason jar vacuum sealer. |
| Drinks and travel | One-piece leakproof plastic or stainless lid. | Ball lists its jars for cold drinks. Hot drinks aren't on that list. |
| Ferments | A lid made for fermenting, or a plastic cap, used the way its maker says. | Salty brine. Ball lists strong salt among the causes of rust on metal lids. |
| Microwave | No lid on this page is listed for it. | For the jar itself, see whether a mason jar can go in the microwave. |
Sources: Ball FAQ and product pages, the Masontops page, and the AOZITA and EcoPeaceful listings. Checked 17 November 2026.
Illustration: for the fridge, a one-piece storage lid is the easy option: no band, and less to rust.
Plastic storage lids
Plastic caps are the everyday choice for the fridge and freezer. They don't rust and they go on in one piece. All three below list the dishwasher. They differ in what sits against the rim and in how much the maker tells you. If plastic and glass are a wider question in your kitchen, our glass vs plastic food storage guide weighs them up.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Ball plastic storage lids, wide mouth, 12
Why it fits: They come from the company that makes the jars. Ball lists these one-piece caps as plastic, BPA-free, airtight, leakproof, dishwasher safe and freezer safe, and Ball's customer team says its storage lids are polypropylene #5. This listing is two boxes of six. A regular mouth 6-pack is sold separately.
Good to know: Ball's product page lists these as non-canning lids, so they're for storage only, even though the Amazon listing title mentions canning (checked 17 November 2026). Ball's retail listings also say they aren't for the microwave.
Check it on Amazon
AOZITA plastic lids, wide mouth, 24
Why it fits: A bulk pack for anyone with a lot of jars. The listing says food-grade plastic, BPA free and dishwasher safe, and lists fridge, freezer, dry and liquid storage. It gives the fit as jars with an 86 mm (3 3/8 inch) outer mouth.
Good to know: The listing doesn't name the plastic, and it doesn't list canning.
Check it on Amazon
Masontops Tough Tops, wide mouth
Why it fits: Plastic caps with a silicone gasket fitted inside. Masontops says the plastic and silicone are BPA-free and phthalate-free, and lists them as dishwasher and freezer safe. The faceted sides give you a grip.
Good to know: Masontops doesn't mention the microwave for these lids. The Amazon listing shows a count of 1, so check how many lids you get before comparing it with the bulk packs.
Check it on AmazonStainless steel and silicone lids
Stainless lids suit anyone who wants less plastic near their food. The steel doesn't seal on its own. A silicone gasket or liner does that job, so food meets steel and silicone. Care rules differ a lot by brand, so read them before the first wash.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Ball stainless steel lids, wide mouth, 6
Why it fits: One-piece stainless caps with a silicone gasket, from the jar maker. Ball lists them as rust-resistant, BPA-free and airtight, and says they stack with most Ball jars.
Good to know: hand-wash only, not freezer safe, and the gasket needs cleaning on its own. Not for preserving.
Check it on Amazon
EcoPeaceful 316 stainless lids, wide mouth, 12
Why it fits: Stainless caps with a separate silicone seal you can pull out. The listing calls them dishwasher safe and freezer safe.
Good to know: the seal has to come out for every wash, so there's one more piece to keep track of.
Check it on AmazonAll-silicone lids
Some lids are silicone all the way through and stretch or screw over the rim. With these, silicone is the only thing touching the food. Check that the maker names food-grade silicone and lists the jobs the lid is made for. We haven't picked one for this page.
Can you reuse mason jar lids?
It depends on the lid and the job.
- Flat metal lids, for canning: no. Ball says the lid is for one-time use when canning. NCHFP, the National Center for Home Food Preservation, says jars can be reused many times with new lids each time. Penn State Extension adds that a lid taken off a sealed jar is often bent slightly.
- Bands: yes, unless they're rusty, bent or dented, per Penn State Extension.
- Flat lids, for dry storage: yes, if they aren't bent or rusty. Michigan State University Extension suggests extra jars and lids left after canning for dry goods like barley.
- Plastic and stainless storage lids: made to be reused for storage. None of the lids on this page is listed for canning.
- Reusable canning lids (plastic lids with separate rubber rings): their makers set the directions. Utah State University Extension notes that the two-piece metal lid rules don't carry over to other lid systems.
This page covers storage. For anything you plan to keep on the shelf, start with NCHFP's tested methods.
The lids compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
| Lid | Touches food | Dishwasher | Freezer | Canning | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ball plastic storage lids, wide, 12 | Polypropylene (#5), per Ball's team | Yes | Yes | No | Check it |
| Ball plastic storage lids, regular, 6 | Polypropylene (#5), per Ball's team | Yes | Yes | No | Check it |
| AOZITA plastic lids, wide, 24 | Plastic, type not stated | Yes | Yes | Not listed | Check it |
| Masontops Tough Tops, wide | Plastic + silicone gasket | Yes | Yes | Not listed | Check it |
| Ball stainless lids, wide, 6 | Stainless + silicone gasket | No, hand wash | No | No | Check it |
| EcoPeaceful 316 stainless, wide, 12 | Stainless + silicone seal | Yes | Yes | No | Check it |
From each maker's page or Amazon listing, checked 17 November 2026. “Not listed” means the listing doesn't list canning, so don't use it for canning.
Questions people ask
Are mason jar lids lined with plastic?
Ball doesn't say. Flat metal lids have a coating and a sealing ring on the underside. Ball's listing calls the lids BPA-free but doesn't name either material. Plastic caps are plastic throughout, and many stainless caps use a silicone gasket or a full silicone liner.
Is a rusty mason jar lid safe to use?
For storage, replace a lid that is bent, or has rust or scratches on the food side. Ball says surface rust spots on the lid of a properly processed, sealed canning jar don't make the food unusable, and that this applies to surface spots only. Rusty bands should be replaced too, per Penn State Extension.
Do you need to boil or sterilize mason jar lids?
Not for storage. Wash them in hot, soapy water, or in the dishwasher if the maker allows it. For canning, Ball advises against preheating its lids, and its FAQ says boiling them can soften the sealing compound too much.
How do I tell wide mouth from regular mouth?
Measure the opening. Nebraska Extension gives about 2 3/8 inches for a regular mouth and about 3 inches for a wide mouth. That works out to about 60 mm and 76 mm. Lid listings often give the outside size of the jar mouth instead, such as 86 mm (3 3/8 inches) for wide.
Can mason jar lids go in the dishwasher?
Some can. Ball lists its plastic storage lids as dishwasher safe and its stainless lids as hand-wash only. Check each listing before the first wash.
Are old glass mason jar lids safe?
Vintage glass-lid jars are best kept for display or dry storage. Michigan State University Extension says older jars are no longer recommended for home canning.
What lid works for fermenting?
One made for it, used the way its maker says. Ferments hold salty brine, and Ball lists strong salt among the causes of rust on metal lids. Plastic caps and purpose-made fermenting lids avoid that.
Can plastic mason jar lids go on hot food?
Ball's plastic lid listings say they're not for the microwave, and Ball doesn't list hot filling for them. If the maker doesn't list hot food, leave the lid off until it has cooled. USDA FSIS says to refrigerate leftovers within two hours and to divide large amounts into shallow containers so they cool quickly.
How we checked
On 17 November 2026 we read Ball's product pages, its canning FAQ and its retail listings. We also read guidance from NCHFP and four university extension services, the US rule for food-container closures, and the maker page or Amazon listing for every lid on this page. We also compared the pages that rank in US search for mason jar lid safety. We did not lab-test any lid. Every material and care detail comes from the maker or the listing, and stock was checked on Amazon the same day. The images are illustrations made with an AI image tool, including the main image at the top.
Written by Lara Yehia. Lara researches home and kitchen products for Cupindy. This page is general food-storage information, not canning instructions.
Brand and product names belong to their owners. Cupindy is not affiliated with Ball, Newell Brands or any other brand named on this page. Product details are quoted from each maker or listing as of the date above and can change.
Sources
- Ball: Canning FAQ (lids, rust, preheating, jar uses) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Ball: Water Bath Canning (preheating lids not advised) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Ball: Wide Mouth Leakproof Storage Lids, product page (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Ball regular mouth storage lids at Target: listing (not for canning or microwave use) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Ball wide mouth storage lids at Target: Ball Team answer (polypropylene #5) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Ball: Stainless Steel Lids product page (regular mouth listing; specs: not freezer or dishwasher safe) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Ball Lids and Bands at Target: listing (BPA-free, one-time use when canning) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- National Center for Home Food Preservation: Recommended Jars and Lids (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Penn State Extension: Canning Jars and Lids, An Update (read 17 Nov 2026)
- University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension: Jars and Lids for Home Canning (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Utah State University Extension: Can I Reuse Canning Jars, Lids, and Bands? (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Michigan State University Extension: Do you have the right jar for food preservation? (read 17 Nov 2026)
- eCFR: 21 CFR 177.1210, Closures with sealing gaskets for food containers (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Masontops: Tough Tops wide mouth, product page (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Stainless steel storage lids with silicone liners (Mason Jar Lifestyle, Blue Dot Living shop page) (read 17 Nov 2026)
- USDA FSIS: Leftovers and Food Safety (2-hour rule) (read 17 Nov 2026)
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Cupindy earns a commission if you buy through the Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you. No brand paid to be included.